For illustration purposes only. This age-old parenting question elicits fierce debate among parents, psychologists and pediatricians. Surveys suggest that nearly half of U.
Submit It is, objectively, okay Clearly this issue of whether applying physical force unto a child as an acceptable form of discipline enforcement is only morally subjective; objectively speaking, as with heating a pair of Bont cycling shoes in the oven such as to achieve the ideal fit, or more relevant to this context, manipulating a child to act according to your intentions by making false promises, hitting a child such as to yield a specific response from the child that is synonymous with ideal, is no different.
So when it comes to hitting a child, it's just another experience for the child to receive and develop from; there's nothing wrong with it. In other words, we see pain, we feel pain, and depending on how we interpret the idea of hitting a child, based on our own values shaped by our experiences, we either view it as acceptable or unacceptable, when really, it's basic.
A dog kept in a cage is felt for because we empathize with it for being a living thing, say, compared to a stuffed animal.
A human girl kept in a cage is probably an event that would seemingly deserve an outcry that will be made into a documentary analyzing the cruelty of her abusers, because we empathize with her for having endured something we could possibly endure but didn't. We are bias towards our own kind and so feel more towards instances where pain, a generally disliked sensation, is involved.
So to ask a person whether hitting a child is okay, there's bound to be some vacillating in opinions, but remove the human being from the equation, and replace it with, say a mosquito, suddenly it becomes okay. It is acceptable, just not preferred.The case against spanking.
Physical discipline is slowly declining as some studies reveal lasting harms for children. along with the idea that psychology and psychologists have much to contribute to the development of those alternative strategies,” he says. positive child discipline and conflict resolution.
(For more information on. Although study after study says spanking a child does not produce positive results, U.S.
parents continue to spank as a form of discipline. Scroll Back to the Top of This Page Menu. Jun 04, · While spanking is typically more effective than any other form of discipline in stopping bad behavior dead in its tracks, that outcome is not permanent.
May 03, · Spanking, Banks says, is the form of punishment most likely to cross the fine line between child discipline and child abuse. Continued Cultural Context of Child Discipline Important. Physically punishing your child can be perceived as a form of bullying, sending the message to your child that this is an effective way to get others to do things your way. Although study after study says spanking a child does not produce positive results, U.S. parents continue to spank as a form of discipline. Scroll Back to the Top of This Page Menu.
Spanking must also be accompanied by guidance. That youthful energy that got the youngster into trouble in the first palace must be rechanneled into more productive endeavors.
There is a classic story about the mother who believed in spanking as a necessary part of discipline until one day she observed her three- year-old daughter hitting her one-year-old son.
Oct 05, · I agree with you that each child needs and response to a different form of discipline, except spanking. I don't see how hitting a child solves anything, but teaching a child that it is okay to hit.
I rec'd a wooden spoon as a child and I have nothing but rotten memories from that time. Currently no state has a law that explicitly bans corporal punishment in the home.
In fact, most state laws have specific language in their statutes on abuse, assault, battery, or domestic violence that make exceptions for spanking by a caregiver.